ITL Baseball

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Thursday, 28 November 2013

Philosophy and Dr Who

Posted on 05:00 by blogger
In the 50th anniversary special of Dr Who, The Day of the Doctor, there was a very intriguing philosophical moment that I thought might be interesting to unpack here. It occurred during a negotiation between shape shifting aliens and humans: the aliens had assumed human form and the negotiations between the two parties were going nowhere. The Doctor arrived and wiped their memories with his magic wand (er, sonic screwdriver) so neither party knew whether they were human or alien and they had to negotiate with one another from a position of ignorance. Thus the treaty that would be hammered out between humans and aliens would have to be scrupulously fair, because when your memory came back you wouldn't know which side you'd be on. 
Rawls
...
Anyone who has studied political philosophy over the last 35 years will immediately recognize this scenario. It is the so called Original Position from John Rawls's book A Theory of Justice. Much of contemporary political philosophy has been a critique of Rawls from either a communitarian, liberal or libertarian standpoint. What Rawls says is this: imagine you had a bunch of people who were a designing a brand new society - now what if these people didn't know if they were going to be rich or poor, man or woman, black or white, disabled or abled, gay or straight, etc. - what would that society actually look like? Rawls's thought experiment allows a "veil of ignorance" to descend over the negotiators (rather like the Doctor's memory wipe) so that they would end up designing the most "just" society that they could possibly come up with. Rawls's Just Society that comes out of this Original Position has universal healthcare, laws against discrimination, equality for women, enhanced social mobility, protections for minorities etc. - To me it looks a lot like Canada or Denmark. And although what Rawls produced was only a thought experiment he says its a useful one. (Other political and ethical philosophers dispute both the idea of the veil of ignorance and what the laws of the just society would look like.) Rawls claims that we can use this conception of the Just Society to criticize cultures that are very far from his model - societies where there are great disparities of wealth, where minorities and women are not treated well etc. 
...
You can get A Theory Of Justice at all good university bookshops or online. My favourite critiques of Rawls are by the philosophers Michael Sandel, Alasdair MacIntyre, Robert Nozick and Ronald Dworkin. 
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Alasdair MacIntyre, Dr Who, John Rawls, Michael Sandel, Robert Nozick, The Original Position | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • 15 'Great' Big Books You Don't Have To Read
    Life is short, you've got a lot to do and you still havent watched The Wire or read War and Peace. Well I haven't watched The Wire e...
  • Jerusalem by Jez Butterworth
    Yesterday was St George's Day so I thought I'd trot out this post from last year ... ... It's not very fair to review a play on ...
  • When Will The Oil Run Out?
    I haven’t found an adequate answer for this question on the net (just a lot of silliness and/or propaganda) so I’ve had to do the sums mysel...
  • Philip Larkin
    Philip Larkin would have been 91 years old today (had he not died of cancer in 1985). Larkin's reputation has only grown since the 80...
  • What Dungeons and Dragons Teaches You About 9/11, Conspiracy Theories And, Er, Real Life
    A blogpost from October of last year... ... As Jesse Ventura might have said conspiracy theories - like religions - are for the weak. I was ...
  • My 10 Favourite Books Of 2013
    I'll probably do a separate list for crime fiction, but in the meantime here are my favourite books of 2013, not all of which were actua...
  • A Theory About Horror Movies
    a blogpost from March of this year that got a lot of comments... ... My older daughter was at a sleep over party last week where they watche...
  • Where Did The Irish Come From?
    I won't draw out the suspense, the simple answer is Spain. I think the evidence is now pretty definitive that Ireland was populated from...
  • Autobiography - Morrissey
    Morrissey trying to conquer the world of literature and attempting to bring back the cream denim jacket look; only one of these goals is hub...
  • The First American Newspaper Review of The Cold Cold Ground
    It's been nearly 4 months since The Cold Cold Ground was released in the US and finally the book has gotten its first full length newsp...

Categories

  • .the big lebowski
  • 10 greatest rock memoirs
  • 2013
  • a journey
  • a matter of life and death
  • a supposedly fun thing I'll never do again
  • a time of gifts
  • accents
  • Adelaide Writers Festival
  • Adrian McKinty
  • Alasdair MacIntyre
  • Alicia Stallings
  • american splendor
  • Aranaldur Indridason
  • Atlantic Civilization
  • australia
  • autobiography
  • backstroke
  • barack obama
  • Barry Cunliffe
  • BBC
  • belfast
  • Belfast Poet Laureate
  • Belfast Riots
  • ben wheatley
  • bjork
  • bleeding edge
  • Blue Highways
  • Borgen
  • breaking bad
  • brienne
  • Bruce Chatwin
  • carrickfergus
  • chad harbach
  • Charles Sprawson
  • Charles Willeford
  • cheers and boos
  • cheesy
  • China Mieville
  • christopher nolan
  • coen brothers
  • colin harrison
  • colum mccann
  • Connie Wilson
  • cormac mccarthy
  • crap
  • crash
  • creep
  • dan brown
  • Dan Stone
  • Dana King
  • Daniel Dennett
  • dashiell hammett
  • david foster wallace
  • david logan
  • David Lynch
  • david peace
  • declan burke
  • Denmark
  • derry
  • DNA
  • Douglas Hofstadter
  • down in the ground
  • Downton Abbey
  • Dr Who
  • duel
  • Edgelands
  • Edward Thomas
  • elanor catton
  • Elmore Leonard
  • Elysium
  • Expedition to the Barrier Peaks
  • faber and faber
  • Falling Glass
  • first review
  • FX
  • Gabrielle Drake
  • Game of Thrones
  • Gene Wolfe
  • george orwell
  • gravity's rainbow
  • Halldor Laxness
  • harvey pekar
  • haunts of the black masseur
  • homeland
  • I Am A Strange Loop
  • I hear the sirens in the street
  • ian rankin
  • iceland
  • in the morning I'll be gone
  • independence
  • Inferno
  • inherent vice
  • interactive murder map
  • ireland
  • Irish
  • Israeli Flags
  • Jack Batten
  • jack vance
  • jaime lannister
  • JD salinger
  • Jerusalem
  • Jez Butterworth
  • jg ballard
  • JK rowling
  • Jo Baker
  • joe queenan
  • john mcfetridge
  • John Murray
  • John Rawls
  • John Searle
  • Jonathan Lethem
  • jonathan swift
  • Kill List
  • Kirk
  • kiryas joel
  • lamed shapiro
  • law and order
  • Liverpool FC
  • locked room mystery
  • locked room problem
  • London Orbital
  • long list
  • Lost In Space
  • louis macneice
  • M and G diner
  • matt damon
  • Melbourne Age
  • memoir
  • Miami Blues. Penguin Crime Classics
  • michael chabon
  • Michael Sandel
  • Michael Symmons Roberts
  • millers crossing
  • Molly Drake
  • Morrissey
  • Motherless Brooklyn
  • murder ballads
  • murdering twinmaker
  • nadir
  • Neill Blomkamp
  • Nerd of Noir
  • new york times
  • nicholas bouvier
  • Nick Drake
  • nyrb
  • obvious parody
  • of monsters and men
  • oxford parks
  • patrice oneal
  • Patrick Fermor
  • patrick leigh fermor
  • Paul Farley
  • penguin
  • philip larkin
  • PrairyErth
  • Radio Silence
  • radiohead
  • raymond chandler
  • red hall
  • Red or Dead
  • red rocks
  • review
  • Richard Cowper
  • Richard Curtis
  • River Horse
  • Robert Galbraith
  • Robert Macfarlane
  • Robert Nozick
  • rules of writing
  • Sawston
  • SBS
  • scotland
  • screenplay
  • sightseers
  • sigur ros
  • sinead morrissey
  • soap opera
  • Spain
  • Spinetingler
  • spinetingler award
  • star trek
  • Stephen Donaldson
  • stephen oppenheimer
  • Steven Dougherty
  • tasmania
  • terry pratchett
  • the 47 ronin
  • the americans
  • the australian
  • The booker prize
  • The Broken Road
  • The City And The City
  • The Clash
  • the coen brothers
  • The Cold Cold Ground
  • The Counselor
  • The Cuckoos Calling
  • the dude
  • the dying earth
  • The Fortress of Solitude
  • the greatest westerns
  • the handsome family
  • The Icknield Way
  • The Mind's I
  • The Ned Kelly Awards
  • the new york yankees
  • The Old Ways
  • The Original Position
  • the pittsburgh pirates
  • The Shetland Islands
  • the st kilda sea baths
  • the sugar cubes
  • the swimmer as hero
  • The Toronto Star
  • The Undertones
  • The Unlimited Dream Company
  • The Wall Street Journal
  • the way of the world
  • the yiddish policemen's union
  • thomas covenant
  • thomas pynchon
  • tokyo
  • Tony blair
  • TransAtlantic
  • transporter
  • trolling
  • uncool baseball teams
  • university of minnesota
  • v
  • vineland
  • wanker
  • werner herzog
  • WH Davies
  • William Least Heat Moon
  • woody allen
  • WW2 novel
  • yiddish

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (100)
    • ►  December (10)
    • ▼  November (10)
      • Philosophy and Dr Who
      • Alaska Schmalaska
      • In The Morning I'll Be Gone - The First Review
      • Literary Geography
      • Why Dr Who Matters
      • Autobiography - Morrissey
      • Borgen Is Back
      • The Fix Is In
      • Books Of The Year - November Update
      • Morrissey On Lost In Space
    • ►  October (12)
    • ►  September (10)
    • ►  August (12)
    • ►  July (11)
    • ►  June (10)
    • ►  May (11)
    • ►  April (10)
    • ►  March (4)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

blogger
View my complete profile